[email protected] +91 9840521421 Scholarly Open Access, Peer-reviewed, Refereed Journal e-ISSN 2582-8746 Since 2020
  1. Home
  2. Archives
  3. 2026
  4. Vol. 7 Issue 6
  5. Article
Original Article

Development of an Evaluation Framework for Claimed Quantum Advantage in Quantum Machine Learning Using Published Benchmark Results

  • Paper ID 1214
  • Volume 7, Issue 6
  • Pages 92-99
  • Published Online: November-December 2026
Open Access Peer Reviewed Crossref DOI

Authors

  • Al-Amin Ajao1

1 Independent Researcher, Lagos, Nigeria.

Article Information

Published Online
November-December 2026
Pages
92-99
Article Type
Original Article
Check for updates
check update

Abstract

View PDF

Reports that quantum machine learning (QML) models outperform classical ones are common, but the evidence behind them is uneven. This paper develops the Quantum Advantage Evidence Framework (QAEF), a rubric that grades the evidence behind a published QML performance claim using only what the paper reports. QAEF scores seven criteria from 0 to 2:classical baseline strength, tuning parity, problem scale, hardware execution, statistical rigour, evidence that the quantum component matters, and reproducibility. Every score cites where the study reports it, and three gates stop a high total from masking a missing classical baseline, absent tuning parity or an untested quantum contribution. Applied to 15 peer-reviewed studies from 2021–2024, QAEF rated one study Strong, six Moderate, six Weak and two Unsupported. Tuning parity was the least-met criterion, and only two of eight advantage claims used strong classical baselines, against four of five parity claims. The only Strong grade went to an advantage shown on quantum rather than classical data. The full evidence sheet is given in the Appendix.

APC from ₹1200 + 18% GST

Peer-reviewed open access₹1200 Indian (₹1400 with DOI)$80 USD internationalpaid after acceptance Peer-reviewed open access₹1200 Indian$80 USD international ₹1200 Indian · $80 intl

  • CrossRef DOI
  • ISSN 2582-8746
  • Open Access
  • Peer Reviewed
  • Plagiarism Checked
  • Google Scholar
Submit Paper